-
- Price band
-
£ £ £ £ £
- ABV
- 52.7%
- Production type
- Single malt whisky
- Region
- Islay
- Flavour camp
- Fruity & Spicy
- Nose
Rather fresh and clean, with gentle apricot, some sweet baking spice that shifts to oxidised fruit, apple, some fruit eaux-de-vie and a background funkiness. Found this one a bit tricky, but it starts to grow on you. Water adds in some pecan pie as the sweet, patisserie elements begin to take over. There’s this slight alcohol burn.
- Palate
A silky-soft start with yellow fruits galore, some dessert apple, more of the apricot/peach, then some cinnamon toast and Bunna’s mix of sweet mash, hazelnut and ginger. Like many brandy casks, things become slightly rigid in the middle as the finish begins to exert itself, but though it becomes increasingly firm, there’s enough lift and vibrancy there. It needs time and water in order to mellow and bring the two halves together.
- Finish
Drying, slight brandy butter burn.
- Conclusion
It starts off very much as a game of two halves, but ultimately it works.
- Right place, right time
A mix of Wine and Honey.
- Price band
-
£ £ £ £ £
- ABV
- 55.7%
- Production type
- Single malt whisky
- Region
- Islay
- Flavour camp
- Fruity & Spicy
- Nose
Chewy, with red fruits galore – the Port seems to have taken charge in this relationship. Strawberries, redcurrants, a glimmering of something darker – hawthorn jam, perhaps? – in the background. Grows in boldness as it begins to open, adding a savoury edge. Water opens up the sweet trolley to the full.
- Palate
The generosity of spirit is there from the start, as Bunna’ begins to make its presence more clearly felt. We’re back to hazelnut (but now in a Nutella-esque way), then some cherry pie filling. There’s a surprisingly mature undertone to this – whiffs of cigar lounge and old-style whisky bars – that’s then given a cooked berry fruit lift. Becomes very spicy in the centre, with some burn in the mid-palate, though this is sorted out by a judicious splash of water, though again it’s the finish that’s taking charge here – there’s also a little drying wood.
- Finish
Fruit, light anise, hint of sloe.
- Conclusion
Easier-going structurally than the brandy, but the three years of extra maturation in Port has the wine in charge. That said, it’s an easy-drinking early evening companion.
- Right place, right time
The dark enfolding you, then lit with Hits of Sunshine.
- Price band
-
£ £ £ £ £
- ABV
- 47.4%
- Production type
- Single malt whisky
- Region
- Islay
- Flavour camp
- Rich & Round
- Nose
This has a rich, almost vinous quality that initially gives off strawberry chews and light plum, but then moves into marmalade, some apple and an earthy, cacao note. There’s some of the dried rose petal you only get with age, along with scented woods and hints of clove oil. Rich and well-balanced. Water adds light, almost maritime notes, initially at least, with a return to the light red fruits: raspberry juice/rose cordial, rhubarb, before it starts to deepen and shape-shift into something darker and more dangerous.
- Palate
There’s some wood here from the off, alongside that slightly burnt raisin quality which you can get from Marsala casks. As things start to open, you get an intriguing mix of After Eights, ginger (very Bunna’) in syrup, then a huge hit of liquorice allsorts (savoury-sweet, coconut and dried fruit). Water brings out the oak more, drying things down. Things have shifted to the nutty side compared to the first pair and, while there’s still some of the pâtisserie on show (brioche this time), the hazelnut is now toasted. A late flaring of soft fruits gives a nodule of sweetness towards the back, but things start to dry and fade slightly.
- Finish
More oaky (but hey, it’s 31 years old), with chocolate and a drying, almost ashy finish.
- Conclusion
Mature, a little oaky, but overall rich and complex.
- Right place, right time
Stewing things down in the kitchen, making Marmalade.
- Price band
-
£ £ £ £ £
- ABV
- 50.6%
- Production type
- Single malt whisky
- Region
- Highland
- Flavour camp
- Rich & Round
- Nose
Deep, sweet and lightly pruney, with some cereal back notes. Moving towards figginess and tinned prunes. That said, it’s also retained sweetness – there’s a touch of vanilla and buttercream icing and a tiny hint of red fruits, which brings both sweetness and lift, adding to the complexity. Water enhances this steamed figgy pudding quality, alongside more resinous qualities.
- Palate
As the nose suggests, this is sweet and highly concentrated, starting with deep, heavy chocolate, some tobacco and lots of iced gingerbread. There’s a flare of heat in the middle before it resolves itself back into those figs again. It’s here, in the softly-textured mid-palate, that Deanston’s signature citrus comes in to perk things up, alongside a return of dried raspberry/raspberry leaf. It then progresses into spices: mace, clove especially. With water added, you get some more mature notes (leather), as well as freshness (red cherry). Things remain generous and ripe.
- Finish
Slight peppery heat. Dried fruit.
- Conclusion
This started off in recharred casks, then spent some unspecified time in oloroso casks from Montilla-based organic producer Robles. Rather than being dominated by the finish, it is enriched. Classy stuff.
- Right place, right time
Lying in the open air under the honeyed moon.
- Price band
-
£ £ £ £ £
- ABV
- 55%
- Production type
- Single malt whisky
- Region
- Highland
- Flavour camp
- Fruity & Spicy
- Nose
Immediately bright, fresh and fruity, with zingy citrus dominating: spiced orange, tangerine marmalade, light almond and a distinct waxiness reminiscent of scented candle. In time you get some olive playing alongside the fruit syrups. With water, there’s some sweet nut and a light chalkiness. Upfront and energetic.
- Palate
Warm and soft to start, with concentrated, lightly oxidised fruits and a touch of bran on the sides, before things soften in the middle of the tongue, where it is all butterscotch toffee, thick peach juice and orange blossom honey. As seems to be the case with Deanston, it’s here that the spices start to kick in – and do so fairly dramatically. Has drive and real energy, but is balanced. Water makes things more oxidised and, by calming the spiciness down a notch, makes things more rounded overall.
- Finish
Lightly acidic. Mandarine Napoléon.
- Conclusion
Only £65? Bargain of the week – and marked in its competitive set. There’s only 268 bottles though…
- Right place, right time
A Frisky little number.
- Price band
-
£ £ £ £ £
- ABV
- 51.8%
- Production type
- Single malt whisky
- Region
- Highland
- Flavour camp
- Fruity & Spicy
- Nose
Opens with the pleasant fuzziness you occasionally get from good Sherry-casked whiskies. Working your way through that, you can pick out fruit salad, overripe melon, soft dried fruits (sultana especially) and citrus peels. The waxiness seen on the fino is more overt here: beeswax-polished wood. Everything is ripe and mellow. There’s some nougat-like nuttiness when water is added, alongside hints of toffee which provide another layer to the mix of (now dried) citrus peels, banana skin, fruit trifle and black cherry.
- Palate
Chewy, sweet and rich to start, with sweetness taking off to the extent that you wonder if it’s got enough grip and acidity to balance. There’s fruit trifle, ripe nectarine, then the date. The mid-palate remains soft and tongue-coating, but here the mature elements and the wax start to spread out. There’s some country house elements, light leather, dried fruit while, when the spices come in, they have the earthy pungency of cumin and the acidic brightness of sumac. When water is added, there’s more orchard fruits layered on top, as well as Seville orange peels giving a twang of bitterness.
- Finish
Peaches and spices, then some chocolate.
- Conclusion
Deanston is on fire with this trio. This has more depth and complexity than the fino and is less heart-on-the-sleeve than the oloroso. Classy.
- Right place, right time
All is in balance.
- Price band
-
£ £ £ £ £
- ABV
- 52.9%
- Production type
- Single malt whisky
- Region
- Islands
- Flavour camp
- Smoky & Peaty
- Nose
Big and smoky, with the smell of an old copper coin/just polished brass, then a whiff of stable/tack room and linseed oil. No real manzanilla influence, as far as I can see. When water is added, you get some rubbery notes; then cigarette ash and kippers – the stale yet pungent smell of the breakfast room in a rundown Hebridean hotel.
- Palate
Big, oily, slightly earthy and meaty and, as ever, teetering on the brink of being grubby, but this time it saves itself with a mid-palate hit of minty sweetness and rich, cooked red fruits. The wood and the smoke are integrated; some woodsmoke, smoked cereal, some treacle-cured bacon and tar. With water, thick, briny and oily.
- Finish
Tarry. The first Gitanes of the day.
- Conclusion
A dirty burger that’s been saved by the barbecue sauce.
- Right place, right time
Wiping the Greasy Gravy off your chin.
- Price band
-
£ £ £ £ £
- ABV
- 55.7%
- Production type
- Single malt whisky
- Region
- Islands
- Flavour camp
- Fruity & Spicy
- Nose
Quite a funky opening: all stewing fruit, old citrus peels and almond, with a slight meatiness behind. There’s a distinct weightiness here. When water is added, you get more wet, earthy notes, alongside vegetable stock cube then finally the concentrated, raisined fruits. The distinctive whiff of an old bookshop, stuffed with leather-bound, slightly foxed tomes.
- Palate
Starts with rich, fruity weight, some peachiness, touches of raisin and then the slightly singed/liquorice signature from the Marsala cask. As it relaxes, so you can pick out more soft plummy weight, though that runs alongside the artificial flavour of an isotonic drink. It needs water, which brings out fresh orange, more sweetness, riper fruits and, finally, some camphor.
- Finish
Drying and short.
- Conclusion
It’s neither one thing nor the other.
- Right place, right time
In a quiet corner, Grievin’ at the Mishnish.
This week, we’re really spoiling you with an extra batch of new whisky tasting notes from Dave Broom, as he gives his full attention to Distell’s eight-strong line-up of Limited Release single malts for 2019, including whiskies from Bunnahabhain, Deanston and the Mull tag-team of Tobermory and Ledaig.
The range covers a lot of bases in terms of cask types, encompassing finishes in Marsala, Port, French brandy, plus a Sherry quartet of fino, manzanilla, palo cortado and oloroso. Variety aplenty.
We open on Islay with a solid trio of Bunnahabhains, the highlight being a ‘rich and complex’ Marsala finish at 31 years of age that evokes memories of marmalade-making.
But, if there’s a standout performance this week, it comes from the sometimes underrated Deanston distillery in the Highlands, which scores a hat-trick of successes and impresses Broom mightily.
The oloroso finish is ‘classy’, the fino finish is ‘bargain of the week’ at £65 a bottle – but the palo cortado finish tops the lot with its extra layers of depth and complexity.
We close with one whisky each from Mull’s double act of Tobermory and peaty Ledaig, but it’s more whimper than bang, thanks to the slightly questionable ‘dirty burger’ qualities of Ledaig and a Tobermory Marsala finish that is ‘neither one thing nor the other’.
The soundtrack ranges from Joan Shelley, Julie Byrne and Linda Perhacs plus, er, Sonic Youth (all in gentle mood) to upbeat Carla Bley and Sly Stone, while Jackie Leven’s sitting sadly at the back of the pub on Mull. Click on the links in Right Place, Right Time to enjoy the sounds.